When Katie's fiance died in a tragic accident, so did her hope of finding love. Seth arrives in Hope Falls to help his brother Amos get back on his feet following the death of his wife, but Katie and Seth find, with the guidance of angel Elias, that they have a future together.

Family problems only strengthen sixteen-year-old Faith's eagerness to be married and join the church, until a local paper publishes a story about a child who was kidnapped fifteen years earlier that raises doubts in her heart.

Rachel Hartzler, the youngest and last unmarried sister of four Amish girls, and Jordan Engles, her father's new hired hand, are hostile to one another at first, but angelic intervention draws them together.