Miriam Lapp returns to the Amish community she once belonged to when she hears of her mother's death. Amidst her grief and some painful lies from her past, she is forced to face the people who rejected her. Losing her once fianc�e and being shunned by her father becomes an excruciating test of her faith.

Sarah's faith is tested after learning disturbing secrets about her deceased husband, and she feels pressure to get remarried in order to ensure stability for her newborn twins.